COINS · SCULPTURE · JEWELRY · STORIESNew to silver? Start here
The collector’s journal

A Bowl Worth Packing: The Silver Écuelle

A Strasbourg silver-gilt broth bowl and its fitted leather case reveal two sides of eighteenth-century design: elaborate display and careful protection.

Two handles, a different setting

The handles spread outward like little stages. Each has its own folds, ridges and curling edges, yet both remain subordinate to the broad circle of the bowl. Above them, the cover rises through several bands of ornament to a small, twisting finial. It is a practical form that seems reluctant to leave any edge undecorated.

In our childhood and family-silver guide, a porringer introduces questions about eating vessels and later family meanings. This covered bowl takes that inquiry into a different setting. The Met calls it an écuelle: a vessel for hot broth or soup. It connects the form with early eighteenth-century morning refreshments during the toilette, the ritual of washing and dressing. That is historical context, not a diary of this bowl’s owner.

Gold-colored covered bowl with two broad scrolling handles, floral decoration and an animal on the lid, photographed on a matching stand.
Silver-gilt bowl and cover, Strasbourg, ca. 1756; 1974.356.679a, b. Shown with the separately numbered stand, 1974.356.680. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, The Lesley and Emma Sheafer Collection, Bequest of Emma A. Sheafer, 1973. Museum record · Public domain.

A quiet band makes the ornament louder

Look at the smooth band below the lid’s decoration. After all those tightly packed lines, its uninterrupted reflection gives the eye somewhere to rest. The contrast matters as much as the ornament itself. Without it, the patterned cover and handles could collapse into a single busy surface.

A small animal stands within a framed space on the lid. Its legs and back are much quieter than the surrounding flourishes; a patient look brings it out of the pattern. The finial repeats the restless movement of the handles, but turns that movement upward. From the outside edge to the highest point, the photograph offers several different routes for the eye.

The museum dates the silver-gilt bowl to about 1756 in Strasbourg. Its maker fields say probably by Joachim-Frédéric Kirstein I and probably by Johann Friedrich Krug. Those are uncertain attributions, not a confirmed partnership. Read the catalogue details. For the wider vocabulary of surface treatments, compare the guide to gilding and decoration.

The second object changes the story

Beside the reflective bowl, the case feels almost like its shadow. The reddish-brown surface swells over the enclosed form, then drops into the spaces around it. Small hooks interrupt the outline. Gold ornament supplies a visual link with the vessel, but the broad leather surfaces make a very different impression.

The Met identifies this as a purpose-made protective case for the bowl and stand, part of a traveling set. It lists dyed, gold-tooled leather and brass fittings. The case record describes the bowl’s maker as either Kirstein or Krug, reinforcing the uncertainty rather than resolving it. Read the case record.

Closed reddish-brown leather case with gold ornament, raised areas following the enclosed vessel and small metal hooks.
Case, Strasbourg, ca. 1756; dyed and gold-tooled leather with brass hooks and eye, 1974.356.684. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, The Lesley and Emma Sheafer Collection, Bequest of Emma A. Sheafer, 1973. Museum record · Public domain.

The closed view leaves the interior out of sight. We can compare the silhouette with the bowl, but cannot use this photograph to describe its lining or the fit of every component. Nor does a traveling case supply an itinerary. It gives us a relationship between objects, not the names of destinations.

Keep the parts distinct, then look together

A bowl, a lid, a stand and a case can make a persuasive ensemble in a photograph. Recording them separately makes that ensemble more intelligible, not less. Here the vessel and cover share one accession entry, while the stand and case have their own numbers. The distinction prevents a photograph of several components from becoming an inaccurate description of one.

Try looking at the two images in reverse order. Start with the case’s practical outline, then return to the metalwork. The emphatic handles and raised finial no longer seem only decorative: they are shapes that another maker had to accommodate. The attraction is in that conversation between display and protection.

Continue with The Silver Table, or use the object-record guide to keep the identities and evidence for a group of objects together.

Share this resource.