Does an overlapping stamp mean it’s fake?
Not on its own. An overstrike is a stamp punched partly or entirely over an earlier one. Sometimes the overlap is a trace of two workshops doing business, not an attempt to fool a collector. But it doesn’t prove a piece is genuine, either. You still need to work out what the stamps say and how the object and its records fit together.
On a teapot made for Hannah Carter, the stamp J. Austin crosses Revere. Turn over the matching stand, and only Revere appears. Six surviving teaspoons carry only J. Austin. Yet all of them are engraved with the same letters: HC. The U.S. State Department’s diplomatic collection catalogue describes the marks and records in note 3. The coffeepot pictured on that page is a different object.
What do the teapot, stand and spoons say?
| Piece | Punched mark | Engraved initials |
|---|---|---|
| Teapot | J. Austin over Revere | HC |
| Matching stand | Revere, not overstruck | HC |
| Six surviving scalloped teaspoons | J. Austin only | HC |
The initials are a cipher, or a design made from a person’s letters. They belong to Hannah Carter, not to either workshop. A seller who shows you only the stand has shown you one real piece of evidence, but not the whole set of marks. And a spoon that says J. Austin doesn’t necessarily tell you who made it. In this case there’s a bill to check.
Can a bill tell us who made the silver?
In 1787, Paul Revere Jr. charged Nathaniel Austin for twelve scalloped teaspoons, twelve plain teaspoons, a pair of tea tongs, and the engraving of twenty-five ciphers. Austin billed William Smith, who married Hannah Carter that year. Six of the scalloped teaspoons survive at Yale, according to the State Department catalogue. Their Austin punches are what you can see; the bill is what connects the order to Revere’s shop.
The teapot isn’t on that 1787 bill. In her study of Revere’s workshop, Deborah Anne Federhen suggests a separate 1790 entry may refer to it. That is a proposed match, not a receipt showing what happened to this exact pot. The marks and bills make a good case for trade between the shops. They don’t tell us exactly when the second stamp was struck or whose hand held the punch.
The papers also give us a glimpse of the people behind the initials. In a letter to Hannah in April 1816, Abigail Adams remembered William as someone she had loved like a brother. Each had felt at home in the other’s father’s house. The letter says nothing about a teapot. It does give Hannah a life beyond the two letters on her silver.
Why would two workshops put their names on one piece?
Another Boston order shows how work could be divided. In April 1762, Revere billed Nathaniel Hurd for two small scalloped salvers. Both survive at the Worcester Art Museum with the Franklin arms engraved on their faces. Revere made the salvers; Hurd engraved them and added his own mark on the front. The Met’s catalogue, entry 39, note 4 identifies the pair and the ledger entry; Federhen describes the division of work.
That’s a different kind of evidence from an Austin punch covering part of Revere’s name. Two marks can be two tradespeople’s signatures, or the trace of a piece passed between shops. They can also be something else entirely. The question isn’t just how many marks you see. It’s where they are, what kind they are, and whether any record explains them.
What should I photograph on my own silver?
- Show where the mark sits. Take an overall picture, then one of the entire underside. Put the pot, stand and any loose pieces in separate photos so you know which mark belongs to what.
- Take a close-up in side light. Try a lamp from one side, then the other, and take at least one photo straight on. A shallow shadow can bring out a faint letter. Don’t polish or scrape to make a stamp show up.
- Save the owner’s initials separately. Put their location and wording in your notes. Transcribe the letters you see; use a question mark for the ones you’re only guessing at.
A photo can preserve a clue, not settle authenticity or silver content. Start with how to document a piece, then compare maker’s marks, fineness and plating marks. For a different kind of mystery, John Pintard’s initials offer an example of a name that helps trace a piece without identifying its maker.