COINS · SCULPTURE · JEWELRY · STORIESNew to silver? Start here
The collector’s journal

Silver for the Erie Canal: A Gift and Its View of Progress

Two silver vases for DeWitt Clinton turn a canal into a civic tribute. Explore their makers, classical forms, changing landscapes and the limits of celebration.

A gift with an argument

A silver vase can do more than hold something. It can honour a person, announce who is doing the honouring and give a public event a lasting shape. Two monumental vases made by Thomas Fletcher and Sidney Gardiner for New York governor DeWitt Clinton do all three. Their subject is the Erie Canal; their material turns civic gratitude into something conspicuous and durable.

The Met identifies the patrons as a group of New York merchants and the place of manufacture as Philadelphia. The two objects have separate catalogue dates, 1824 and 1825, and were presented to Clinton in 1825. Each rises to about sixty centimetres. These are not ordinary flower vessels made grand by a later story: the commission itself was commemorative.

Read them alongside our history of silver sculpture. The useful question here is not simply how much silver they contain. It is how that silver makes a case for the canal, and what a celebratory object can leave outside its frame.

Silver presentation vase with twisting paired handles, a covered bowl, an eagle finial and a central engraved architectural scene above a square footed base.
Presentation vase, Thomas Fletcher and Sidney Gardiner, Philadelphia, 1824. Silver. The Metropolitan Museum of Art; 1982.4a, b.
Collection credit and image source

Purchase, Louis V. Bell and Rogers Funds; Anonymous and Robert G. Goelet Gifts; and Gifts of Fenton L. B. Brown and of the grandchildren of Mrs. Ranson Spaford Hooker, in her memory, by exchange, 1982. Museum record and additional views · Public domain.

A design before the opening

In her study of the Clinton vases, curator Beth Carver Wees traces the project to a competition announced by Pearl Street merchants in December 1823. They wanted a pair sharing a form but differing in ornament. Fletcher and Gardiner’s Philadelphia firm won. The canal would not open until October 1825: the silver was part of an unfolding campaign of recognition, not merely a souvenir commissioned after the celebrations.

Wees also reproduces Fletcher’s correspondence. Writing to his wife Melina on March 12, 1825, he described plans to exhibit the vases in New York and explain their design. He and Isaac Hone would prepare a description for publication. The letter brings the maker into the story as an interpreter as well as a supplier: elaborate silver needed words to direct its audience’s attention.

The two pieces still reward that alternation between looking and reading. From a distance, their symmetry, broad handles and eagle-topped covers establish a commanding presence. Closer in, small framed scenes interrupt the ornament. They ask the viewer to move from the whole monument to a particular place along the canal.

An antique form for a new landscape

The Met connects the bodies and handles to the ancient Roman Warwick Vase. But the American objects are not straightforward replicas. The borrowed form supplies a grand container for a different programme of images.

Look at the vase dated 1824. Its handles sweep outward in thick, twisting bundles before returning to the body. Beneath the cover, a broad patterned rim forms a strong horizontal line. The central landscape occupies a quieter rectangular field, bordered by figures and ornament. Below it, the vessel narrows into a stem and then expands again onto a square base with projecting feet.

The museum identifies the front scene as the canal’s guard lock and basin at Albany, accompanied by Mercury and Ceres, associated here with commerce and agriculture. These identifications belong to the catalogue. In the photograph, one can follow the architecture and water within the central panel without pretending that every small figure is equally easy to read.

On the vase dated 1825, the corresponding front panel shows Cohoes Falls, flanked by Fame and History according to the museum. The shared outline gives the pair coherence, while the landscapes divide the story between them. Each eagle is positioned above the lid, making the summit of the design a different sort of emblem from the classical figures below.

Silver presentation vase with an eagle-topped cover, large twisting handles and an engraved waterfall scene on the front of the rounded body.
Presentation vase, Thomas Fletcher and Sidney Gardiner, Philadelphia, 1825. Silver. The Metropolitan Museum of Art; 1988.199.
Collection credit and image source

Gift of Erving and Joyce Wolf Foundation, in memory of Diane R. Wolf, 1988. Museum record and additional views · Public domain.

Whose progress is being celebrated?

The patrons’ interests matter. A gift from merchants to a canal-promoting governor is not a neutral survey of everyone affected by the project. Its imagery can make commercial expansion look orderly, productive and worthy of remembrance. That is part of the object’s historical meaning, not a reason to stop looking at its craftsmanship.

The Erie Canalway National Heritage Corridor places the waterways within the ancestral homelands of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy and the Mohican Nation. Its historical account describes canal development as accelerating Indigenous dispossession and disruption, processes already under way before construction. These were inhabited homelands, not an empty landscape awaiting improvement. The same account recognises the Nations’ continuing presence and contributions.

In the Met’s current audio discussion, environmental researcher Renée Barry interprets a depicted Indigenous figure beside a felled tree; scholar Lemir Teron foregrounds harms to Haudenosaunee and other Native peoples. Barry’s imagined contemplation is interpretation, not recorded testimony.

That distinction matters. A figure placed within a nineteenth-century decorative scheme cannot speak for the communities whose land was transformed. Nor is the reverse scene shown in our two front-view photographs. The museum discussion provides another way into the objects, but it should not be confused with something the photographs alone prove.

Looking again at presentation silver

Return to the raised handles and the small landscape panels. The same object now holds several scales of attention: the skill required to organise a large silver form, the route imagined through its scenes, the merchants’ public gratitude and the histories that gratitude did not encompass.

The design’s beauty and its argument are not separate layers that can simply be peeled apart. The ordered pair, the classical references and the conspicuous material help make the commemoration persuasive. A plain inscription might name Clinton; these vases give the tribute a whole visual world.

For a collector, that suggests a richer way to approach presentation silver. Ask who paid for it, whom it addressed and what the imagery asks its audience to admire. Then look for histories beyond the dedication. Acknowledging those histories does not require inventing a private motive for every maker or patron. It requires recognising that a commissioned tribute presents a particular view.

Our guide to the materials of silver sculpture begins with another essential question: what is the object actually made of? Here both museum records say silver. Material, form and public purpose belong in the same account. Together they make these vases more than glittering illustrations of an engineering achievement.

Share this resource.