Two boxes, more than one history
One sugar box sits low on little feet, its broad oval body gathered beneath a domed lid. The other stands upright, with a flower on top and a small harvesting scene enclosed by restless ornament. Both are silver. Neither can be understood simply as an expensive container for something sweet.
The first, dated about 1710, is attributed probably to John Coney, with Daniel Greenough identified as retailer. The second was made by Paul de Lamerie in London in 1744/45. They are not a set, an original-and-copy pair or evidence of a relationship between the two workshops. Read together, however, they reveal two kinds of distance: between a mark and the people who made an object, and between table luxury and the labour represented on it.
The casket and its uncertain maker

The earlier box is almost all horizontal movement. Slanting ribs run around the lower body and across the lid, carrying the eye towards the decorated clasp at the front. Above, the ring handle breaks that horizontal outline. A coiled snake wraps around its base, while the feet lift the body clear of the surface below.
In entry 34 of Early American Silver, the Met explains why the attribution is qualified. The box bears a mark associated with Greenough, but its feet, handle and construction resemble examples marked by Coney. The indistinct mark’s unusual position inside the body raises the possibility of Greenough stamping over Coney’s mark. The catalogue proposes a retailer commissioning another workshop, not a proven sequence of events.
A mark is therefore not always the end of the inquiry. Here it starts an argument involving comparison, construction and business practice. Calling the box simply “by Greenough” would erase the distinction the catalogue makes; removing his name would erase his recorded role as retailer.
The current record lists New Castle, New Hampshire, while the catalogue considers a Boston workshop as a possible supplier. These are not grounds for inventing a documented journey from one bench to another. The maker remains “probably John Coney.”
Sugar did not belong only to tea
The same catalogue places this casket form in the serving of wine, which could be sweetened with sugar. That broader history matters: a sugar box is not automatically proof of a tea service. Nor does a general account of a form establish the exact contents or occasions of this particular box.
By contrast, the Met describes the de Lamerie box as probably belonging to a set with green- and black-tea canisters. The qualification must remain. Our silver tea-set guide introduces the assembled service; this comparison asks what can be learned when a component is studied on its own.
The earlier box presents its contents through a casket-like form. The later one goes further, putting an image of production on the outside. Before reading that image as a reassuring story of abundance, look closely at who is doing the work.
A harvest made into ornament

On the de Lamerie box, the front scene occupies a relatively quiet panel within a densely worked frame. A palm bends across the upper left; a small figure is low to the ground beneath it, among vegetation and cut stalk-like forms. Around the panel, curling edges swell and contract. Face-like forms emerge near the shoulders, and a flower crowns the lid.
The object record identifies cane harvesting and notes the workshop’s combination of figures with abstract organic ornament. The Met’s British Galleries primer makes a more pointed interpretation of this same box: the kneeling worker is enslaved, and the sugar trade’s prosperity depended on coercion and violence. The primer’s illustrated box matches the object shown here.
Those readings are not alternatives from which to choose the more comfortable one. A finely made decorative scene can also make exploitation look picturesque. The small scale of the worker, surrounded by luxuriant plants and elaborate silver borders, is part of how the scene is presented to a viewer at the table.
This is an image fashioned for a luxury object, not testimony from the person depicted. It does not give us that person’s name, experience or voice. Recognising enslaved labour in the museum’s interpretation should make us more attentive to that absence, not encourage an invented biography.
What the boxes do and do not establish
The two objects ask different questions of their evidence. For the earlier box, a marked surface does not settle who made it. For the later one, an ornamental surface does not make the work it depicts harmless. In both cases, the first attractive or apparently simple answer is incomplete.
Yet the comparison has limits. These records do not identify the plantation, shipment or geographical source of sugar actually kept in either vessel. They do not establish that the earlier box and the later harvesting scene were directly connected. Acknowledging the documented history of enslavement is not permission to manufacture an individual chain of supply.
It is possible to attend to workmanship without isolating it from history. The ribs of the casket, the shaped clasp, the upright box’s flower and curling frame all deserve close looking. So do the uncertain workshop roles and the human cost behind a supposedly gentle scene of harvest.
Continue with Paul de Lamerie’s workshop for the larger business context. Here, the most useful lesson is more demanding than admiration alone: keep the pleasure of looking, but ask whose work has become visible, whose has been made decorative, and what the surviving evidence cannot recover.