The two Fish and Waves bracelets at LACMA are by the same designer, Margot van Voorhies Carr. They represent two stages in her career. Around 1940 she designed the silver bracelet for Los Castillo. In the example dated about 1955, she returned to the motif at her own Margot de Taxco workshop and used enamel to bring out parts of the design. One is not the other bracelet with color added later.
Start with the fish, then read the labels
Open the museum’s circa-1940 silver bracelet and follow the incised curves of the waves. The pattern changes at the bodies of the fish: tight lines pick out scales while thicker edges pull the eye onward. Now open the circa-1955 silver and enamel bracelet. Blue and green help you separate the fish from the curling forms around them. The metal still does part of the drawing. The color makes the eye read it differently.
Curator Rachel Kaplan connects the motif to Japanese ceramics and textiles. The museum records identify two Taxco-made Mexican works, not Japanese jewelry. Their relationship is unusually well documented because the catalogue for each bracelet points to the other. For a collector, that makes them a better comparison than two listings that happen to use the same title.
It helps to look twice. On the first pass, follow the overall rhythm of the fish and wave curls. On the second, pick one fish and trace where its outline ends. In the silver bracelet, the surface and incised lines have to carry that distinction without color. In the enameled bracelet, hue can draw your attention to a neighboring surface before you notice its edge. You don’t need to prefer one to see why the pair is useful: it lets you see what changes when color takes on some of the work of a line.
What changed when the workshop name changed?
The Castillo brothers had worked in William Spratling’s workshop before setting up Los Castillo. Margot became Los Castillo’s lead designer. She later ran the workshop named Margot de Taxco. You do not need to agree on an exact opening date to read the museum labels: the earlier entry credits her as the designer for Los Castillo; the later piece comes from her own shop. The earlier attribution does not make it a Spratling design. And it is a reason to write “by whom?” and “for which workshop?” on two separate lines in your notes. Taxco jewelry guide.

For a collector facing a mark, the distinction between designer and workshop is especially useful. A stamped workshop name isn’t a list of all the people who worked on a piece. Nor does it mean that one design could never be revisited elsewhere. In this case, start with the makers as the museum records them, with Margot designing for Los Castillo in the earlier entry and Margot de Taxco responsible for the later workshop. If you enter “Taxco” as the maker of both, you lose the very difference that makes the pair interesting.
The hands that put the color in
Champlevé enamel is colored glass fused into recessed areas in metal. Those recesses help explain why the silver and color can share a single boundary. But technique is only part of the story. In UNAM’s Revista 925, Alan Gómez Monjaraz draws on interviews with people who knew the shop. Salesman Jaime Quiroz recalled that Margot carried a magnifying glass to look closely at things she might draw. The article names María Elena Flores among the enamelers, Velarmina Palacios as a lead in that section, and Vicenta Rodríguez as a later lead. Melesio Rodríguez became head of production. The enamelers worked from Margot’s designs and directions. That account tells us who did this kind of work in the shop; it does not identify which person enameled the museum bracelet. Read the UNAM workshop account.
Penny C. Morrill’s study of the shop follows the work back a step. Margot and Sigi Pineda developed the enamel process together, and Arturo Sorio made steel dies from Margot’s drawings. In this technique, the metal ridges help keep adjacent colors apart. That little border is not just a drawn line: it does a job. Morrill’s account explains a division of labor in the shop, not whose die or hands made this exact museum piece.
Tulane’s Taxco exhibition puts two other designs beside finished objects: Margot’s 1955 serpent drawing near a green enamel serpent bracelet, and her 1950 Village Man and Woman drawing near a silver, enamel and leather bolo. It’s worth looking at what a drawing can tell you, and what becomes visible only in the finished object.
The drawings offer a useful way to separate evidence of design from evidence of production. A drawing can show where a curve, join or color was planned. It cannot show how the actual clasp feels or how an enamel edge catches the light. The finished piece supplies information the drawing cannot, and the drawing supplies information you’d miss if you only looked at the maker’s name. Neither example in the exhibition is a production record for the two Fish and Waves bracelets.
If you’re comparing one at home
Start with photos of the front, the underside and the way the bracelet closes. Read the whole mark before interpreting a name or number. Record areas of color loss, damage or repair separately from the design and do not assume a plain piece was once enameled. These LACMA records give materials, but no fineness. A resemblance does not establish the maker, date or alloy of your bracelet. For those separate questions, use the Taxco marks guide and Taxco construction and care guide.
Set one comparison photo beside each object in your notes, rather than saving a folder full of nearly interchangeable fish. Note what matches the museum example and where the details diverge. Is the resemblance in the whole outline, in one line of scales, or in the way the color meets the silver? Those observations are useful even when no exact match turns up. They are also easier for someone else to revisit than a confident attribution with no photographs attached.