Three objects, one household story
A kettle, a basket and a bowl do not look like a matching set in the simple sense. One rises above a lamp, another spreads outward beneath an arched handle, and the third sits low on the table. Yet the Metropolitan Museum of Art identifies these three London objects as parts of a larger silver service owned by the Philadelphia merchant David Franks.
All are catalogued to Paul de Lamerie and dated 1744–45. Their connection reaches beyond a shared maker’s name: engraved heraldry joins the pieces to Franks and his wife, Margaret Evans. The result is a story about how a household’s silver can be recognised after its components have travelled separately.
Start with the kettle. Its tall dark handle creates an almost empty oval above the densely worked body. Beneath the vessel, three legs give the stand a wide stance. Light passes through the space between kettle and feet, so the silhouette combines a substantial container with an open framework. It is both an object for handling and a remarkably elaborate piece of table sculpture.

London workmanship, Philadelphia ownership
The Met places the service within the movement of English luxury goods to the American colonies. These were London-made objects in a Philadelphia household, not examples of local manufacture. De Lamerie’s workshop supplied an unusually elaborate version of fashionable rococo silver.
The distinction matters when looking at a collection. An owner’s city does not necessarily tell us where an object was made. The service connects an Atlantic trading world to a domestic setting, but the connection is not a surviving scene: we cannot reconstruct a particular gathering around these pieces from their presence alone.
Our Paul de Lamerie profile introduces the maker’s wider work. Here, three different forms let us look at the workshop’s visual range. The kettle needs a spout, lid and handle; the basket offers a broad open interior; the bowl places its principal decoration on a continuous curved wall. Their family resemblance is not produced by repeating one outline.
Openwork, volume and the changing surface

The bread basket is the most open of the three. Its sides are pierced with curling shapes, allowing the grey photographic background to enter the design. A narrow handle rises from opposite sides, but it is not a plain strip: its attachments swell into sculptural ornaments. At the rim, irregular projections disturb the otherwise broad oval.
Compare the kettle’s rounded body. Here the surface holds light in larger patches. A central shield sits within a raised, scrolling frame, and ornament gathers around it. The contrast between the relatively smooth vessel and its crowded embellishment makes the engraved centre a place to pause.
The bowl handles the same problem at a smaller scale. Its top edge opens out above a rounded wall; beneath, shell-like forms create a low, spreading base. A framed shield faces the viewer, flanked by plant-like ornament. The interiors of all three objects are not equally visible, and the photographs were not made to a common scale. The museum gives the kettle’s overall height as 37.5 centimetres, the basket’s height with its handle as 28.6 centimetres, and the bowl’s as 9.8 centimetres.
Those measurements return the eye to the table. The bowl is not a miniature version of the kettle: it occupies a different level and has a different shape. For more on the range of objects associated with tea, see our guide to silver tea sets.

The evidence that ties a service together
In “London Silver in a Colonial Household,” published in 1967, curator Jessie McNab Dennis linked matching London hallmarks for 1744–45 with engraved arms pairing the Franks and Evans families, an arrangement associated with marriage.
The Franks arms alone did not distinguish David from his brothers; the Evans connection helped identify the household. Dennis proposed that the engraving was added in Philadelphia in the 1750s. This remains her interpretation, not an inscribed date.
This makes the shield more than another flourish. Among the scrolls and shells, it introduces a different kind of pattern: a family relationship expressed within a decorative object. The silver asks us to look closely and then to look beyond its surface.
The current Met labels describe a marriage-related purchase as likely. They do not establish a documented commission or identify a proven wedding donor. It is enough to keep the possibility open without turning it into a scene of a gift being ordered, shipped or presented.
Separate paths into one collection
The modern acquisition credits reveal another kind of separation. The kettle entered the Met as a gift of George D. Widener and Mrs. Eleanor Widener Dixon in 1958. The basket came through the Helen Flynn Conway bequest in 1966. The bowl was given by Irwin Untermyer in 1968. Three current entries, three accession histories, one recognised earlier service.
That pattern is a useful counterweight to the idea of a set as something permanently intact. The matching arms can persist when the objects no longer share a room. Museum research can reconnect them intellectually without supplying every missing step of ownership.
Looking again at the photographs, the variety becomes the point. A tall kettle, an airy basket and a shallow bowl can speak the same decorative language without looking interchangeable. Their common history is carried through different uses and proportions, while each object retains a separate later life.
This is silver at two scales: the surface close enough to study, and the household or trading world that the surface helps us recover. Neither should erase the other. The maker’s work remains worth looking at, but the engraved arms turn that looking into a question about people.
A note on the marriage date. The current Met labels give 1744; Dennis’s 1967 article, page 177, gives December 1743. We leave that disagreement explicit rather than assigning the silver’s 1744–45 date to the marriage. The proposed marriage connection remains an interpretation, not a resolved commissioning history.