COINS · SCULPTURE · JEWELRY · STORIESNew to silver? Start here
The collector’s journal

What “Pure Coin” Means on Antique American Silver

Two cups from an 1851 Georgia prizewinner’s household show why coin silver isn’t pure silver, and why English sterling need not be made in England.

A prize for floral design

At a fair in Macon in October 1851, Mary Anne Hammond Washington won a silver cup for floral design. The design itself is not recorded here. The cup has its own pair of flowering stems worked in relief, with space between them for her initials, surname, and the award. It is only three inches high. If you saw it upright in a cabinet, you could learn who won it and when without seeing the mark that tells you what kind of silver it was meant to be.

Floral relief and an engraved award on the front of a footed silver prize cup.
The 1851 prize cup, engraved for M. A. Washington’s floral design. Smithsonian National Museum of American History, DL.60.0990. Gift of Mrs. Ellen Washington Bellamy. Public domain.

The fair was held by the Southern Central Agricultural Society. An account preserved by the University of Georgia Press describes a horticulture program and records silver cups among the prizes. The surviving account and the object do different jobs. The fair record shows how silver fit into the event. Washington’s own cup supplies the award wording, month and year. It does not tell us which flowers she used, what her design looked like, or what the cup cost.

Why “PURE COIN” does not mean pure silver

Turn the cup over. Between scraps of an old paper label is a triangular stamp, transcribed by the Smithsonian as PURE COIN. There is no maker’s mark reported on this cup. The number written in ink is a collection identifier, not a fineness number.

Underside of the 1851 cup. Paper remains and inked collection numbers frame a faint central mark.
The museum reads the faint central stamp as PURE COIN. The handwritten number is a catalog identifier. Smithsonian National Museum of American History, DL.60.0990. Gift of Mrs. Ellen Washington Bellamy. Public domain.

In this context, coin silver was an alloy, generally about 90 percent silver in nineteenth-century U.S. work. There is a numerical reason for the term: the federal Mint act of 1837 set U.S. silver coinage at 900 parts silver and 100 parts copper. That provision governed coinage, not the manufacture or testing of this cup. Some smiths did melt coins for their metal. As the Winterthur conservation team explains, the coin marking also remained in use when shops bought sheet silver instead. The letters cannot tell you which happened here. Nor has the museum record supplied a measured silver percentage for the cup.

An easy distinction to remember: about 900 parts per thousand describes the customary alloy; “made from melted coins” is a claim about where the metal came from. The latter requires its own evidence. Neither is the same as elemental silver.

The other cup has a New York address

A later silver mug belonged to the same woman. Its base is much easier to read. A curved line says ENGLISH STERLING above 925-1000, which conveys 925 parts silver per thousand, or 92.5 percent. The base also has two G & W marks and an impression with Tiffany’s name and 550 Broadway. The museum dates this mug to 1854–1865, catalogs it as made in New York City, and names Tiffany as the retailer. “English” here is part of the stated standard, not evidence that the mug crossed the Atlantic. The Tiffany mark is a shop trail, not a reason to call every punch on the mug Tiffany’s maker mark.

Cylindrical silver mug with an ear-shaped handle and finely engraved floral decoration.
The second mug has bright-cut flowers and carries a New York retailer’s stamp. Smithsonian National Museum of American History, DL.60.0993. Gift of Mrs. Ellen Washington Bellamy. Public domain.
Mug base showing a ring of Tiffany lettering around the 925-1000 fineness and other punches.
Under the mug: ENGLISH STERLING / 925-1000, two G & W stamps, and Tiffany’s 550 Broadway mark. Smithsonian National Museum of American History, DL.60.0993. Gift of Mrs. Ellen Washington Bellamy. Public domain.

The catalog does not identify the maker. The New York Historical owns a separate child’s mug with a comparable arrangement of marks and attributes its manufacture to Grosjean & Woodward. It is a useful parallel for someone reading G & W, not a substitute for attribution of Washington’s mug.

How the pair stayed together

The Smithsonian credits both pieces to Ellen Washington Bellamy, Mary Anne’s daughter. They share accession 71656. The museum numbers distinguish the objects; the shared accession and the named donor help reconnect them. One is a dated award with no recorded maker; the other gives an alloy and a retailer but no comparable story about how it came into the home. Together they show why a mark is strongest when read beside what can still be recovered about the object.

If you have a piece marked COIN

Photograph the whole piece and its base. Use angled light to catch shallow letters and copy the punches separately, including their spelling, shapes and positions. Record an engraved name or date separately from the struck marks. For a collector, the distinction is practical: a name can be an owner, maker, or seller, while a numeral may be a fineness, model number, or inventory mark. A stamp is a clue to look up, not a test result. Avoid polishing away patina or scratching an object just to make one mark easier to read. If composition matters for value or treatment, ask an experienced specialist about appropriate non-destructive examination and its limits. A photo can make the clues clear; it cannot put a number on the unseen metal.

Keep reading

Share this resource.